No.
(But they can be)
Final Part.
Part Four. Biblical argument against Mormons being Christians.
I wish the only proof I would have to write to convince my brothers in Christ, members of the universal church (body of Christ), and my neighbors that Mormons are not Christians could come from the Bible. But everyone does not trust in the words of the Bible. They do not use it to define the words they speak. Some do not even believe there should be a standard to define who a Christian is and that tolerance and acceptance of others should reign supreme (more on tolerance later, another topic). I hold the bible to be the only trustworthy authority in all matters. It is the complete revealed word of God.
One reason Mormons are not Christians is because of their belief about the authority of the bible. The official doctrinal position of the LDS faith is not to accept the bible as being “translated correctly” (Article Eight of their Faith, www.lds.org, Articles of Faith). So any proof or argument made from it according to their point of view may not be based on the true word of God additional revelation and knowledge is needed beyond the bible to obtain the truth. So this appeal is more to my brothers in Christ those who hold the bible to be the authority and a call for them to refrain from expanding the tent of Christianity or the title of Christian to apply to our LDS neighbors.
They are distinct in their beliefs and as Christians we ought to be distinct in our beliefs.
Being able to call yourself a Christian in its simplest form depends on following Christ and not chasing down a false christ. There is more to being a Christian than the definition of Who Christ is, but if this single point of doctrine differs then why are further proofs needed? I am not going to cite all the Bible verses that point to the distinct differences between the concept of the LDS Christ and that of the Christ of Traditional Christian. Only eleven words from the Bible are needed. Apologetics of the LDS faith may need reams of paper or megabites of data to make the argument that they are Christians, but God only needs eleven words. Again I believe in the power of God and in His words, not in the arguments of men. (Psalm 119; Hebrews 4:12, 2 Timothy 3:16-17)
“For in him dwelleth all the fulness of the Godhead bodily.” Colossians 2:9 (KJV, www.biblegateway.com)
This is a simple teaching of who Jesus is. He is God. There is one God and the Godhead lives within the physical body of Christ (Jesus). This means that for God the Father and the Holy Spirit (Ghost) to reside in fulness within the body of Jesus, they would not possess their own physical body. It does not confine God to only exist within the body of Jesus, but there is no physical division of God. God is not spread into more than one physical body. (see also Hebrews 1:3) [If I am in error about this understanding of God, show me from the Bible were I am wrong? and I will humbly accept the correction.]
The First article of faith in the LDS faith states “We believe in God, the Eternal Father, in His Son Jesus Christ, and in the Holy Ghost.” (www.lds.org, Articles of Faith) The definition of the Godhead for the LDS faith. Again from the foundation of belief in the LDS faith based on the supposed first visitation (not vision) of God to Joseph Smith, jr. He clearly states that there were personages (more than one) visiting him. If that is true then How could the fulness of the Godhead in personages dwell in Jesus bodily? Personages can not dwell in the same Personage. This difference by itself points to a different Christ (and a different God).
One Christ defined by the Bible and universally accepted by all who call themselves Christians.
Another false christ defined solely by a single man claiming to restore a lost gospel and the first leader of a people who should continue in their distinctiveness and remain “Mormons”. (Perhaps Brighamites is a better term, research the history of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day saints, www.utlm.org)
The real questions that might need some exploring begin with, “are Mormons Mormon?” Do members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints follow the teachings of their prophets and the commands of their God? see my previous post. Is there a unity of their faith? Is the LDS faith on the verge of fracturing again? can practicing polygamists that believe in the Book of Mormon have the same right to self-given titles, can they call themselves Mormon because they differ in some of the current doctrine?
Back to the question at hand, Are Mormons Christians? By the nature of the Christ they follow they are not. But as one of my favorite public personalities who recently passed on Paul Harvey would point to “the rest of the story.” Mormons are not Christians, but they can be. Here is the rest of story.
If “Mormons” want to be called Christians the answer is simple. Do not try to redefine a word to fit your beliefs or make a part-time outward swap of a title or name. But call on the God of Heaven and Earth to make an inward change in your life and cast off the false Christ a personage in a Godhead and seek after the True and Living Resurrected Christ.
Read your bible, put your other books of scripture away. I challenge every LDS to focus on reading your bible and only your bible for one year. And see what picture it paints of Jesus, does he fit inside Mormon Doctrine? I would argue that He does not. Start with Psalm 119 to establish a new trust in the Bible and its words and then go from there.